Stuart Stevens
Awesomeness 3

Does this book do anything right except exposing Mark Salzman’s attitude towards China?

Aspiring American travel writer Stuart Stevens is a huge fan of Peter Fleming. He sets out to retrace Fleming’s and Ella Maillart’s route from Beijing to the Northwest of China. And he doesn’t..

Summary 3.0 meh

Stuart Stevens

Author: Stuart Stevens
Title: Night Train to Turkistan
Time: a winter in the mid 1980s
Destination: China
Length: a few weeks
Type: overland
Rating: 3/10

was it really that horrible?

The story: aspiring American travel writer SS is a huge fan of Peter Fleming. He sets out to retrace Fleming’s and Ella Maillart’s route from Beijing to the Northwest of China. And he doesn’t go alone. With him are two friends and a dude whom we have met before, long term China expat and novelist Mark Salzman.

The quartet takes buses and trains, stays in hotels and hitches rides, and they eventually make it to Kashgar. It is not an easy trip though, mostly because of the pitfalls of post-Maoist bureaucracy and because of the difficulties they meet in underdeveloped areas.

no clue + no sympathy

The resulting book is apparently meant to be funny. SS works very hard to emulate Peter Fleming’s style („From the beginning, it was a silly idea. This, of course, I liked…“), and he manages to keep it an overall light and easy read, something to flip through in one weekend. Still, I didn’t like it very much.

Yes, it is funny and clever to do random things and write about them in a humorous way. But that’s only going to carry so far.

It’s not only the surprising amount of misspellings in the transcriptions that give away the fact that SS doesn’t have the slightest clue about China. His musings about politics or society are mostly superficial, and where they are not superficial, they are often just plain ignorant.

„China was like an army – ugly and inefficient, joyless and numbingly monotonous, with little use for art or literature. Like army posts, the towns all looked alike, disposable citadels of crude function, graceless and hateful. It was a country of uniforms, of Cleaning Brigades and Towel Captains.“

(p.217)

Remember, he is traveling through China in the mid-80s, not the mid-60s. The first notable Chinese heavy metal band Tang Dynasty will be formed in 1988, and Chinese students will make a 10-meter (!) Goddess of Liberty out of papier-mâché on Beijing Tiananmen Square only one year later.

Stuart Stevens looking for hardships

I think what happened here is that SS, influenced by Fleming’s and Maillart’s adventures, wanted the whole journey to be an ordeal. He wanted the country to be hostile, the transportation to be uncomfortable, and the food to be scarce and – if possible – inedible. Sure, Northwestern China has always been a few steps behind, especially when compared to cities like Guangzhou, Beijing or Shanghai. And when you’re on an overland journey, you might have to sleep in hotels where the toilets are clogged up and the electricity goes off at night sometimes. If you choose to go in winter, even the food might be boring! So what?

revelation

There was one thing I found delightful about this book though, a conversation between SS and Mark Salzman.

SS says to Salzman:

„But I got the impression from Iron and Silk that you didn’t really like China.“

And Salzman says to SS:

„I don’t.“

(p.13)

Yep, that about explains all that was odd about Iron and Silk and about this book.

You just can’t write well about something that you don’t feel any sympathy for.

A 3/10.

Leave a comment